Wednesday, 28 August 2013

Response to NHS Health Check criticism

The following post was submitted as a letter to the editor of the Times newspaper last week in response to their leading article on the benefits of NHS Health Checks:

Given the recent conflicting headlines in regard to NHS Health Checks, providers of the programme are understandably confused and frustrated by the inconsistency of the messages being reported in the press.

On 21st July 2013, Public Health England (PHE) announced a drive to extend the national health check programme and widely praised its potential to ‘save up to 650 lives a year’.

Less than a month later on 20th August, the Times ran with the front page headline ‘NHS checks on over-40s condemned as ‘useless’’, with an accompanying article that focussed on a study from the Nordic Cochrane Centre that was originally published and reported on last October. The study alleges that health checks don’t have an impact on morbidity.

Both of these mutually exclusive claims cannot be true at the same time. The pressing question is therefore ‘which is accurate and relevant to the English NHS Health Check programme?’

It should be noted that one of the major criticisms of the Cochrane Review is that it doesn’t actually apply to the current model put forward by PHE. According to the Department of Health’s (DH) response to the Cochrane Review:

‘Most of the trials considered are old, dating from as long ago as the 1960s when understanding of health risks and particularly how they may be modified was at an early stage of development.  Most of the risk reduction measures now used post-date these trials.’

As a result:

‘The review conclusions can have little if any relevance to NHS Health Checks.’

Given how separate the research conditions are from what’s actually happening in this country, it can hardly come as a surprise that the DH rebuffed the Cochrane Centre’s request for the research to be posted on the NHS Health Check website. It was this declined request that the Danish researchers took issue with and condemned in their letter to the Times that acted as the original catalyst for the story.

However, far from being an attempt by the NHS to stifle debate’, it is difficult to see how there could be any assumed requirement for the DH to publish findings which bear no relevance to the English model.

The current approach championed by PHE is – first and foremost – a targeted lifestyle intervention which should encourage positive behaviour change if an individual has poor lifestyle habits. Individuals are made aware of their risk of cardiovascular disease, offered advice and signposted for further support if necessary.

The point is that through the effective communication of risk and appropriate service referral, individuals can fully grasp their likelihood of having a heart attack or stroke and, if needed, be offered support to do something about it.

Moreover, the NHS Health Check is unique in the fact that it combines a number of elements and tests – all of which are ‘based on evidence of clinical and cost-effectiveness from trials’ – and brings them into a single risk assessment programme. As Dr Bill Kirkup, retired Chief Medical Officer at the Department of Health, noted, ‘none of the trials assessed by Lasse Krogsbøll and colleagues tested this’.

I must stress that we fully encourage lively and healthy debate on this blog and recognise that such dialogue is essential to ensure that public health programmes such as the NHS Health Checks are worth the money that’s spent on them.

The issue in this instance is that recent criticism has rested on research that does not accurately reflect or relate to what’s happening on the ground. From an academic perspective, it’s essential that the studies being used in evidence are not disconnected from the reality of the situation.

The discussion as to the merits of the NHS Health Checks is not new. As mentioned, the Cochrane Centre’s findings were first published and in the news last October. This time however the chair of the Royal College of GPs also came out in staunch opposition to the programme.

One of Dr. Clare Gerada’s main claims was that the programme constitutes ‘a waste of money for asymptomatic people’; a statement which translates as ‘if you’ve not already developed complications, you shouldn’t be receiving a health check’.

In response, public health experts appropriately drew attention to the burden of ill health that threatens to overwhelm the NHS during the coming decades. PHE’s official statement written by the organisation's Medical Director - Dr. Paul Cosford - can be viewed here.

It is for precisely these reasons that the programme targets lifestyle factors associated with preventable diseases before they become unsustainably costly for the NHS.

One needs only to look at the facts staring us in the face. It has been estimated that by 2050, ‘90 per cent of today’s children will be overweight or obese.’

Even by 2030, ‘Three in four adults are likely to suffer illnesses such as heart disease or diabetes’ according to the Daily Telegraph’s article from the 21st August; ironically, a publication that only the day before ran with the story about health checks being ‘useless’.

Specifically in terms of diabetes, treating the condition currently costs the NHS £1million an hour. Given the other estimates, the direction in which this financial burden is likely to move looks bleakly clear.

The net financial benefit of acting whilst there’s an opportunity to do so has hard evidence associated with it. As Barbara Young, Chief Executive of Diabetes UK stated to the BBC:

‘Once you factor in the savings in healthcare costs, the NHS Health Check is actually expected to save the NHS about £132 million per year.’

The DH assures that the above figures are based on expert guidance, all of which can be viewed here

Furthermore, research published in the BMJ on the 13th May 2011, found conclusively that:

'A programme across the entire population of England and Wales... that reduced cardiovascular events by just 1% would result in savings to the health service worth at least £30m a year compared with no additional intervention.' 

As a result, once the evidence is examined and objectively considered, the claim coming from the programme’s critics that the Cochrane Centre’s findings constitute the ‘best available evidence’ seems to look less and less empirically accurate.


  1. Prevention and treatment of this disease involve maintaining a healthy diet, regular physical exercise, a normal body weight, and avoiding use of tobacco. Control of blood pressure and maintaining proper foot care are important for people with the disease. Need to know more about diabetes disease

  2. Awesome article, it was exceptionally helpful! I simply began in this and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Cheers, keep doing awesome! best bb cream for dry skin

  3. Thank you very much for this useful article. I like it. Buy Hemp Gummies

  4. In the event that you need to guarantee yourself and your family, at that point you have just a single alternative and this is to purchase medical

  5. Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared a informative and interesting blog post with people.. check it out

  6. Wow! Such an amazing and helpful post this is. I really really love it. It's so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also check it out

  7. Nice to read your article! I am looking forward to sharing your adventures and experiences. learn more

  8. Superbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place.. avis diete 3 semaine

  9. Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it check it out

  10. Very efficiently written information. It will be beneficial to anybody who utilizes it, including me. Keep up the good work. For sure i will check out more posts. This site seems to get a good amount of visitors. comment faire descendre son diabete rapidement

  11. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. A ‘What Dumbbell Weight Should I Use?’ Guide

  12. I am definitely enjoying your website. You definitely have some great insight and great stories. علاج سرعة القذف بالفازلين

  13. Thank you for sharing this great piece of information. I read every single article of yours.
    Keep sharing such informative posts.
    How to Fix WiFi no Hardware Installed Error

  14. Great survey, I'm sure you're getting a great response. CBD Oil for Anxiety

  15. Swiftly this amazing site may well irrefutably turn out to be well-known between almost all writing a blog men and women, as a result of thorough content and even assessments.Pharmacy In Pakistan

  16. For home use, one can either purchase or rent a brand new or used hospital bed from medical supply outlets. Considering that a used hospital bed is far cheaper than buying a brand new one and that the hospital bed will not be utilized for a long time, renting or buying a used hospital bed might be a good option. hasta yatağı kiralama

  17. Health is wealth, and we should take care a lot about our health and spend a good and active life. We should eat proper food and take exercise on daily basis. Because exercise is very important for a healthy life. Dissertation writing services.

  18. lắp camera quan sát chuyên lắp camera wifi camera giám sát chính hãng

  19. Mr Organik is an American Rapper whose net worth in 2021 is $1.Mr Organik Networth this is the best rapper in America and a famous personality.

  20. Bandman kevo is a famous American rapper and singer. Whose net worth in 2021 is $200 thousand NetWorthGorilla he is best rapper I America.

  21. Assignment plays a significant role in a student’s life. However, the sheer mentions of the word’s ‘assignment’ bring annoyance to the students. If you are really struggling to design an assignment, you can always take online options like assignment help.
    On the contrary, if you invest some extra effort and love the concept, you will be able to successfully accomplish an assignment. Also, you will witness the improvement of your academic growth and enhance your writing skills as well.
    Before taking paper help, you should know the fact that why assignment play a major role in a student’s life? Let’s get a brief idea on this.
    Students are given several different topics for an assignment that requires them to get involved in a process that research-oriented and it is rightly said that the brain often develops well while researching.
    Improve practical skills
    Assignment is always helpful to gain practical knowledge on a specific subject. In the process of writing an assignment students get to know a structure or pattern and know the topic really well.
    Improves writing pattern

    Assignment writing requires students to write about a particular topic in detail with all its subdivisions and so on. When you do so you get to improve your writing skills as writing long assignments also helps you to develop a good writing speed in your Marketing Dissertation Topics.
    Time management
    This is one of the most important segments that you need to achieve as a student. The assignments and homework assigned to students need to be completed within a specified time period, which somehow makes them a time savvy.
    To become successful, assignment writing is an essential feature to grasp. But if you feel that you will be unable to execute an assignment without taking operations assignment help, don’t forget to research on Java Assignment Help to get absolute information.

  22. Assignment expert has a team of writers who have been helping thousands of students by their expertise and reliability in writing their assignments, essays, dissertation assignment help writing, assignment writing help in uk and so more. To get all assignment help service from us you can contact us through live chat or call to discuss your requirements. You can also email us your assignment details.

  23. The acronym of WCAG is Web Content Accessibility Guidelines. It offers universal compliance for web accessibility. It is accepted globally and followed by ADA(American with Disabilities Act). The WCAG provides guidelines and other web browsers and provides the best accessible solutions. The best legal solutions derive from organizations that follow WCAG Compliance.
    e-language learning solutions

  24. Hello, I'm happy to see some great articles on your site. Would you like to come to my site later? My site also has posts, comments and communities similar to yours. Please visit and take a look

  25. Thanks for sharing this informative content.,
    Lean pitch provides online training in Agile team facilitation during this lockdown period everyone can use it wisely.