Monday, 20 October 2014

Reviewing the evidence base for NHS Health Checks

The debate as to whether NHS Health Checks represent value for money was given renewed impetus towards the end of 2014 when two new studies into the programme were published in the Journal of Public Health and the British Journal of General Practice

The first of these—a cohort study by Forster et al published in October 2014 in the Journal of Public Health—used a significant sample of patient data (65,324 men and 75,032 women) ‘to estimate the yield of NHS Health Checks’ and assess the programme’s impact. The conclusions of this large-scale study were that the ‘universal prevention programme identifies substantial risk factor burden in a population without known cardiovascular disease’. In other words, NHS Health Checks are effectively revealing CVD risk factors in a large proportion of the 40-74 year old population that were previously presumed to be healthy.

Despite the weight of these findings, those calling for the programme to be abandoned appear to have paid little attention to them. The same however cannot be said for the amount of attention that critics gave to a recent study by Caley et al—published in August 2014 in the British Journal of General Practice—which claimed to assess ‘the impact of NHS Health Checks on the prevalence of disease in general practice’. The authors of this study assert that in 38 GP practices providing NHS Health Checks, the change in reported disease prevalence did not differ from 41 practices that did not provide the checks.

Whilst the programme’s detractors have cited this as evidence that the health checks should be scrapped, a number of researchers and clinicians have since pointed out that Caley et al’s study was, in fact, ‘not powered to support this conclusion’. In addition to there being concerns over the methodology and conclusions, further questions have been raised as to whether those calling for the national programme to be abandoned are basing their arguments on evidence that doesn’t accurately reflect the reality of what’s happening on the ground.

As Dr Matt Kearney—GP and National Clinical Advisor to Public Health England and NHS England—and others have identified, the study was ‘not randomised’, which may explain why it was underpowered to show an increase in disease prevalence. Perhaps more problematic however is that fact that researchers formed conclusions after having considered conditions that are not routinely included in the NHS Health Check.

Despite the authors examining the prevalence of 'hypertension, coronary heart disease (CHD), chronic kidney disease (CKD), atrial fibrillation (AF), and diabetes', as Dr Kearney and others note, CHD and AF are not assessed in the national programme. Although in the longer term you would expect CHD to fall if the health checks proved effective, this would take longer than the three year time frame that the study was confined to. 

This highlights a particular recurring issue in the debate; calls to abandon the health checks have often relied on research that doesn’t relate to the current model put forward by Public Health England (PHE). This was similarly found to be the case with the 2012 Cochrane Review, the conclusions of which the Department of Health say have 'little if any relevance to the NHS Health Checks'. There are a number of reasons for this, one of which was that most of the trials considered were out of date, some from as long ago as the 1960s.

Whilst a number in the health sector have identified Caley et al’s most recently published non-randomised study as lacking the evidence to justify its conclusions, rigorous randomised controlled trials into the NHS Health Check programme do exist. One such study monitored population changes in CVD risk factors over the first year of a new NHS Health Check service. This study – which is available in the Cochrane Library – concluded that the programme resulted in a 'significant reduction in estimated population CVD risk'.

The study also established that NHS Health Check programmes that incorporate Motivational Interviewing and ongoing tailored lifestyle support can 'significantly reduce the prevalence of central obesity'. Given that the UK was recently found to be among the worst in western Europe for the level of overweight and obese people, this insight into the value of high quality consultations is particularly timely. As the evidence suggests, the programme currently promoted by PHE – which is fundamentally conceived of as a supportive and motivational lifestyle intervention – will represent an important component in tackling the nation’s obesity problem, amongst other conditions.

For any public health agenda that takes seriously the notion of patient-centeredness, an essential consideration must clearly be the perspectives of patients themselves. As Janet Krska et al found from carrying out a study that investigated patients' views and experiences of the NHS Health Check, 'both attenders and non-attenders had positive views towards NHS Health Checks in general practice and resultant self-reported lifestyle change in attenders was high'. For this to be the case however, 'clear written information and explanation of personal CVD risk are required'. In other words, the quality of the consultation and support should be noted as repeatedly surfacing as the key to coordinating a successful programme. 

Whilst a number of the aforementioned studies firmly support the value of conducting NHS Health Checks, a nation-wide evaluation is yet to be completed. A forthcoming study by Imperial College London however will address specifically that issue by evaluating whether the national programme 'reduces the burden of heart disease and stroke and other vascular diseases while reducing inequalities in them'. In addition, researchers are investigating the effect of providers delivering patient-focussed health checks that 'extend beyond ticking the contractual boxes'. As has been emphasised in this article, (and as many in the sector would affirm), assessing the quality of health checks must be a fundamental consideration for any meaningful evaluation. 


  1. I contemplated utilizing a CMS for a simple method to make the site however i'd like to include some unique/progressively complex usefulness. What I read so far the thought behind CMS is a greater amount of the board of the site and making static pages. I know there are a few expansions accessible which let you enter php/js code.


  2. شكرا معلومات مفيدة يمكنك زيارة ايضا لمعلومات قيمة اخرى قم بزيارة :

    شركة تنظيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
    افضل شركة تنظيف

  3. These tips are very useful for our health, and we can enjoy a good health because health is wealth. So, always take care of your health and spend a good life. Coursework writing services.

  4. It is truly said that "health is wealth" and every body seeking to get health and also a good diet is the best solution if you want to live a life as you want!
    Custom nursing essay help

  5. Blog of the diagnostics is collected and designed for the standards. Element of the file and matlab homework help is ensured for the chunks. Path is fit for the room of the component for the triple based concepts for the citizens.

  6. Everyone wants their house to be very pretty and look colorful. a Home is a place that is full of samedayessay memories and positivity. If you have a particular photo wall in your house then this will be the best thing about your life. You can order a person who will come to your house and will make a pht gallery there.

  7. The more you invest in your health, the more beautiful and peaceful life you get. I worked on the same topic, while I was giving Dissertation data analysis Services and found interesting stats where I got to know the number of people who lose their lives every day, and mostly die because of several health issues. Therefore, it is very important to look after our health.

  8. It is important to check your health, but not everybody can do it because of small salary. I would like to recommend the best cv review services. that is it.

  9. Technical essays are one where you are given to discuss any statement or any particular idea. The topic can also be in an interrogative form. So, students often search for essay help tips or services to write a compelling essay. Though several generalized tips are available to write an essay, very few of them are specifically valuable for technical essays. So, here is a list of few tips to help students in their technical essay assignments.
    1. Think of a suitable title
    Your title will show much about your perception of the subject. Also, it will be the first thing to attract the readers towards an essay. So, think of some suitable title that goes with the statement or the topic of essays before you start. This is the primary thing done by the professionals, even if you buy coursework help from any writing agency. However, you must be sure that the title you choose shall not disgust readers to read any further. It shall be easy to understand, related to reality where the readers can feel connected to your content. Try to make it simple and profound.
    2. Collect enough information in support of your argument
    A technical essay consists of a writer's opinion and extracts of supporting pieces of evidence for that. Therefore, you cannot just begin to write about something because you feel it to be correct. One has to have enough evidence and examples to prove them correct. You can ask for some samples from a research paper writing service and look into their approach to write a technical essay. It will help you a lot as all the writers in such companies are professionals and are accustomed to every writing rule. You can also ask them to write the entire paper for you if you are still facing difficulties.
    3. Make an impressive introduction and conclusion.
    After the title, your introduction can be the catchiest paragraph for the readers. Try to brief the overall idea or the points you are going to discuss in the introduction. Your introduction shall carry a subtle glimpse of your take on the topic. However, it shall not be lengthy or too monotonous for readers to proceed any further. The conclusion is more or less the same. It concludes the entire extract and refers to the above points as the reason for such a concluding statement. If you are still in a dilemma, you can ask a professional essay writer for guidance or write your essay.
    4. Pay special attention to formatting and structure.
    Formatting and structure are of grave importance in any technical essay. However, the general format for technical papers is title, introduction, abstract, main body and conclusion. But, you shall be attentive if there is any specific format asked in a question. The arrangement also includes the font style, font size and paragraph style for the writing. Generally, it also asked to use references in an essay, so most experienced essay checker recommend APA style referencing in technical essays. However, you can or cannot use other references as per the instructions. If you also feel hard to deal with math then you can opt for math problem solver online.
    Source by-

  10. I'd want to express my thanks to SE DIGITIZING for the excellent quality and timely delivery of the custom embroidered patches. I never imagined I'd be able to acquire the services I needed in such a short amount of time. You rescued my day with your timely and high-quality services. For the greatest and highest quality results, I will suggest them to everyone. Thank you once more.

  11. I have seen posts on Instagram regarding it. I have also shared it on stories to raise awareness for it. A surprising fact is that our society heads are also thinking of hosting a mental awareness campaign in which I have been chosen as a part of the organizing team. But due to my assignments, I am not getting time to participate. So I am thinking of opting for an academic writer who can provide assignment help Uk-based services to me. I will definitely write a blog on it. It would be kind of you if you will read it.